Friday, June 14, 2013

The Battle Begins in Portland, OR

Photo credit: Randy L. Rasmussen/The Oregonian
I just received some news about the annual “Gay Pride” parade in Portland, OR,  in which a number of parishes of the Archdiocese of Portland have participated in the past – complete with parish banners.

The article says:

Parishioners from St. Andrew Catholic Church, which has a longstanding commitment to social justice issues, will march in Sunday's Portland Pride Parade with a banner proclaiming their parish identity, despite the wishes of Archbishop Alexander K. Sample.

At least four Catholic parishes are expected to participate in the parade, according to the Rev. Tara Wilkins, executive director of the Community of Welcoming Congregations. Members of St. Francis of Assisi, St. Philip Neri and St. André Bessette (the Downtown Chapel) also are expected to march. In the past, they have carried parish banners, Wilkins said.

Bud Bunce, spokesman for the archdiocese, confirmed that Monsignor Dennis O'Donovan, Vicar General of the archdiocese, had made the phone call (Fr. Peter L. Smith will take over the office of Vicar General at the end of June, when Msgr. O’Donovan retires).  The article quotes Bunce as saying that the pastor was told that "this was not an event that St. Andrew's parish could be in as a parish."

Ah, but let nothing stand in the way of “gay pride”!

On June 4, [Fr. Dave Zegar, the pastor] met with a group of St. Andrew's parishioners, who decided to stand by their 17-year commitment to Portland's gay community. At Mass on Sunday, Zegar shared the group's decision with the congregation, who responded with a standing ovation

A bulletin insert at St. Andrews last week recounted the history of  the “gay ministry” of the parish, and quoted from the USCCB’s 2006 guidelines on ministry to those with a homosexual inclination:

Essential to the success of ministry to persons with a homosexual inclination will be the support and leadership of the bishop and other pastoral leaders. This is particularly important because more than a few persons with a homosexual inclination feel themselves to be unwelcome and rejected.

The article goes on to comment that

How many feel unwelcome became evident Thursday when the Pew Research Center released the findings of an April survey on the religious attitudes of lesbians, gay men, bisexuals and transgender adults. Eight in ten adults said the Catholic Church, along with Islam and the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, were "unfriendly" to the LGBT community.

You know, it never seems to occur to people who cite these statistics to ask just exactly what it is that makes them feel “unwelcome”. I suppose it is the caveat that even if one suffers from same-sex attraction, one must not act on those homosexual inclinations. The prevailing opinion seems to be that if the Church won’t condone homosexual behaviors, then the Church does not “accept” homosexual persons. That is patently false. The problem is, it’s all about sex - and having it whenever and with whomever one wishes.

So, St. Andrew’s parish, at least, is planning to march in the parade, with a banner.

"The banner is important because it says we are a community of faith," says Jane Braunger, a parish member since the 1980s. "For us not to embrace this statement as a core commitment about openness and acceptance and living the Gospel is cowardly."

Cowardly?! Not. It is just plain disobedient. Not that the pro-gay-pride-parade parishioners (oooh, how’s THAT for some extended alliteration!) see it that way:

"We're not acting out of disobedience," Karwaki said. "We're acting out of obedience to the Gospel and the mission of this parish."

They are acting out of what is, at best, a misguided perception and understanding of the Gospel. At worst, they’ve created a “mission statement” that intentionally runs counter to the teachings of the Church and now insist that they should be able to follow their own “gospel”.  

Pray for Archbishop Sample. He’s going to need it. This is just the beginning!


  1. I don't suppose a bishop can decommission a parish in willful defiance of his demands, and I Mean a whole parish? Just laicizing the pastor won't seem to cure this ailment where the majority if parishioners willfully accept the participation in the parade. I feel that even if the pastor were replaced he'd a) do the same thing or b) the miseducated or false "c"Archilochus majority would fight back with Calumnous letters to the chancery and Nuncio, or financially starve the parish.

  2. The Bishop is the Bishop. If these people are in open rebellion - which they obviously are - then he can and indeed must take decisive action to forbid this. These parishes have thrown the ball right into the Bishop's corner. So now it is up to him. If he caves in, or acts "nice", the sodomites win.

    What's it to be, Your Excellency, "nice" or firm?

  3. Jay,

    Have you seen THIS article about Bishop Skylstad?

    Why, oh why, doesn't the Pope do ANYTHING? Detroit's infamous Bishop Gumbleton is on the list as well.

  4. Just came across your blog in researching this story. Having grown up in Portland and attended St. Francis of Assisi for a year or so as a teenage atheist I guess sadly this story does not surprise me.z

    Pray for Archbishop Sample indeed.

  5. Happy Hockey Mom - actually I have a post on that very topic almost ready to go - though I must admit I didn't notice that Bishop Skylstad's name was attached. Thanks for the heads-up! Hopefully I'll get that post up tomorrow.

  6. Thanks, Jeff Miller, for mentioning my post on your blog!You come up with some pretty good stuff over there!


  7. For many years these parishes have participated in the Gay Pride Parade. I thank St. Andrew's and other Portland Catholic communities for confirming the inclusivity established in the Good News of Jesus. Theuy have stood as patriots, supporting equal rights for all under the US and Oregon constitutions. Ap. Alex may want to re-examine his Portland “evangelizing” efforts by reviewing the words and actions of Jesus, Francis, Bishop of Rome, and the US Conference of Bishops.
    George McCartin, priest/lawyer.

  8. George McCartin, I pray for your conversion and the salvation of your soul.

  9. Thanks for the prayers Dr. Boyd. As age 77 I need all I can get.

  10. Indeed you do, George. We know not the day nor the hour, and we can all use a little conversion. At this point in your life, perhaps it's time to look at what the Church truly teaches and give up the shenanigans.

  11. Pray for the good archbishop indeed, I have a feeling it's going to be quite an uphill battle


Please be courteous and concise.