Thursday, December 22, 2011

Truth Has No Agenda


I have always had a penchant for the truth. Never been any good at lying. Once, as a kid, I snitched a piece of candy from those big open bins in a grocery store; a year later, I confessed that crime to my mother. Okay, I admit the fact that my older sister knew about my misdeed and often used her knowledge to blackmail me (“If you don’t do x, I’ll tell mom about the candy”) was part of my motivation to come clean.


I don’t like it when people deceive me. Until late into my adulthood, I always assumed people were telling the truth. But…they aren't. Sometimes they even lie on purpose!



I’m not always good defending the truth, though. I really hate confrontation, but if the truth is at stake I’ll take the plunge and make it known.

And my voice often does  shake when I am speaking the truth to those who prefer to deny it. That’s why I write!


I love what the Church teaches about conscience, too. It makes so much sense! We do have the Truth written on our hearts; we do know it. But we forget. We deceive our consciences, telling it lies until it becomes numb and can’t function any more.


If we let it go too far, we’re done for.


And when that happens, we’ll buy any happy notion society wants to sell us, just as long as it makes us happy. Then we say, “I am following my conscience.” Sometimes, that’s just not true. Our conscience sometimes is forced to follow us. It’s just a lot easier that way. Not right. But easier.


Speak the truth. Speak the truth in love. I don’t think that means that you have to be oh-so-tactful and gentle and never offend anyone. Remember, the truth comes first. If you are truly speaking the truth, then love IS behind it, even if you are not eloquent or persuasive in speaking it. Truth has a way of being beautiful even when it comes from the mouth of one who is verbally challenged! And you can’t speak a lie in love. It’s a contradiction in terms.

Am I My Bishop's Keeper?

What a bishop is supposed to be, how he is to act: these things are laid out plainly in Canon Law and in various documents of the Church. For instance:

Walking in the footsteps of Christ, the Bishop is obedient to the Gospel and the Church's Tradition; he is able to read the signs of the times and to recognize the voice of the Holy Spirit in the Petrine ministry and in episcopal collegiality. (Pastores Gregis, paragraph 19)

And from the Code of Canon Law (my emphases):

Canon 386 ß1  The diocesan Bishop is bound to teach and illustrate to the faithful the truths of faith which are to be believed and applied to morals. He is himself to preach frequently. He is also to ensure that the provisions of the canons on the ministry of the word, especially on the homily and catechetical instruction, are faithfully observed, so that the whole of Christian teaching is transmitted to all.
ß2  By whatever means seem most appropriate, he is firmly to defend the integrity and unity of the faith to be believed. However, he is to acknowledge a just freedom in the further investigation of truths.

Can. 387 Mindful that he is bound to give an example of holiness, charity, humility and simplicity of life, the diocesan Bishop is to seek in every way to promote the holiness of Christ's faithful according to the special vocation of each. Since he is the principal dispenser of the mysteries of God, he is to strive constantly that Christ's faithful entrusted to his care may grow in grace through the celebration of the sacraments, and may know and live the paschal mystery.

These descriptions, of course, constitute the ideal. But still, they are written into the law of the Church. Bishops, ideally, are good shepherds to their flocks, wise fathers to their priests, promoters of vocations; they are faithful to the teachings of the Church, and they impart their knowledge to the faithful.

Obviously, many bishops – if not all – fall short of these ideals. They are human, after all, just like the rest of us! And because of that, we of the laity are often admonished to be charitable to our bishops (and priests, of course), to pray for them, and to give them a little slack, because leading the faithful is such a difficult job.

Is the job of leading the faithful by example really all that hard, though? Well, yes, I know that there are tightropes to be walked as the media is dealt with, dissident groups and individuals clamor for changes, and those radical traditionalists keep insisting on having an extraordinary form of the Mass available on a regular basis. But then, a bishop is supposed to be a cut above, by the grace of God; he’s held to a higher standard than a parish priest or a layman.

So, yes, the bishop’s responsibility is huge: he is responsible for all of those souls under his care, which includes all of the people of his diocese – even, in a sense, those who are not Catholic. Many a bishop has probably said to himself, “You can please some of the people all of the time, and you can please all of the people some of the time, but you can’t please all of the people all of the time.” And then he tries to do his best to juggle the needs and desires of his flock as he makes administrative decisions.

And there’s the problem: a bishop’s job is not really to please any of the people. A bishop’s job is to please God, and to save souls.

If I were responsible for the souls of all the individuals in a diocese, I don’t think I would spend a lot of time worrying about how to avoid offending people in my statements on issues like homosexual “marriage”, or homosexual priests, or providing a Mass in the Extraordinary Form, or whether liturgical dance should be allowed, or whether children should gather around the altar at the consecration, or…whatever. People will complain about anything and everything. And someone will always be offended.

The Church has spoken on most, if not all, of the issues that come up in parish and after parish, diocese after diocese…year after year. The issues come up because the people have been led to believe that things change in the Church. And indeed, some things do change. The problem is that there are things that can change, and things that can’t. And many of the faithful do not know the difference. In fact, they are so unaware of the difference that many who consider themselves “faithful” simply are not.

Since the Church has rules and regs – and since She teaches the Truth – a bishop need only give voice to what the Church already declares as true. In order to truly care for his flock, the bishop simply must preach the truth. He must preach the truth even if he thinks the “big donors” will stop giving money to the local church. He must preach the truth even if he is crucified in the media. He must preach the truth even if he is crucified by his own flock (just like Jesus)!


If the bishop does not preach the truth (and live it and talk it and publicize it in the mainstream media), but instead subverts Church teaching and directly violates Canon Law, then he leads his flock astray. Period.

And if he leads his flock astray, what is to become of him? Scripture has a straightforward answer:

[Jesus] said to his disciples, “Things that cause sin will inevitably occur, but woe to the person through whom they occur. It would be better for him if a millstone were put around his neck and he be thrown into the sea than for him to cause one of these little ones to sin. (Luke 17:1-2; see also Matthew 18:6)

If I were a bishop, I’d be trembling in fear at those words. I would start thinking about whether I was teaching and preaching the truth of the Catholic Church, or whether I was promoting my own agenda...or someone else’s agenda. And yet, how little thought many of our bishops seem to give to the propriety of their own actions – and the subsequent effect on the faithful! Little ones are stumbling all over the place, because our bishops are unwilling to preach the Truth.

Yes, pray for our bishops. Pray for their conversion of heart, that they might lead us in the way of the Truth of the Catholic Church.

But remember, too, the warning words of Ezekiel:Just as the bishops’ failure to inform their flock about their errors is wrong and harmful to the laity, so too is the laity’s failure to speak up when bishops flaunt the law of the Church and teach wrongly.

The bishop is responsible for our souls, but so are we responsible for his. I am my brother’s keeper, even – and maybe especially – if he is a bishop.

Related posts on this blog:



Tuesday, December 20, 2011

I've Never Seen a Purple Cow...or Bishop

Today, I subject you to my witty, humorous "poetry" .   Without apology.   :-)


We haven’t got a bishop now;
How long before we’ll see one?
Well, I can tell you anyhow,
We hope that soon there’ll be one.

I always thought a bishop would
Adhere to Church law fully.
But now I know a bishop could
Be just a mean ol’ bully.

Ours doesn’t seem to follow rules
Or do what Canon Law says.
He seems to think that we’re all fools
Who can’t see his faux pas-es.

He persecutes the priests who care
And tells us they’re “divisive”.
He acts in many ways unfair.
His comments are derisive.

His tongue has got a silver hue;
He’s selling us the “soft soap”.
Unless Rome quickly gets a clue,
The faithful will have lost hope.

We haven’t got a bishop yet;
We don’t know when we’ll see one.
But when we do, we hope we get
A man who’ll truly be one.


Pray for the appointment of a new bishop!


Parting thought:

We’re gonna get a bishop soon,
If only Rome gets hopping.
But if he has a red balloon,
We’ll still need to go shopping.



Monday, December 19, 2011

Obedience and Our Bishops

Guest Commentary by Jerry Boyd
Absolutely essential to any organization or institution surviving and thriving is obedience to lawful authority.  Obedience on the part of leaders is particularly important.  Where obedience is lacking, especially on the part of so called leaders, a host of very bad things almost inevitably happens.
Within the Roman Catholic Church the ultimate authority, on matters of Faith and morals, is the Pontiff.  Those in positions of lesser authority, Cardinals, Archbishops, Bishops and Priests owe obedience to the Pope on all matters in which the Pope speaks authoritatively.  Failure to exercise obedience leads to an inconsistent and confusing application of Church teaching, and quite frankly scandal to those faithful who are neither stupid nor ignorant of what the Pope directs.  Believe it or not, there are members of the faithful who actually read documents promulgated by our Holy Father and, knowing what they read and understand, have more than just an elementary grasp of expectations and requirements.
So when we know, for example, what  expectations and requirements are in a document like Summorum Pontificum,  and we see that they are not followed, but in fact in some instances are overtly undermined by devious and outright deceptive means, we are in fact scandalized.  And, some of us believe we have a personal, moral obligation to cry “foul” and take all legitimate steps available to us to “right the wrong”.
A series of postings on this blog has been critical of the Apostolic Administrator of the Diocese of Baker precisely because he has taken a series of verifiable steps to subvert the direction of our Holy Father in terms of making Mass in the Extraordinary Form available to those faithful who have expressed a desire for that Mass.  Some have criticized those of us who criticize the Administrator because we have failed to “obey” his direction.  Well, folks, obedience starts at the top, and when the Administrator, a retired Bishop, takes a series of actions directly in violation of Canon Law and clearly disobedient to the expressed will of the Pontiff, responsible Catholics must object.
In fairness, Bishop Skylstad is not the only Bishop (or in his case Administrator, because he is not our Bishop) to defy the Holy Father on matters clearly discussed in Summorum Pontificum.  There are equally objectionable, disloyal, and disobedient behaviors occurring in Dioceses in Texas, Arkansas, and Idaho to name a few.  Actually the list of dissident dioceses here in the United States is likely much more extensive than that.
Unless and until Bishops meet their obligation of conforming their decisions and practices to the will of the Holy Father the newly, focused effort on “Evangelization” is doomed to fail.  What conscientious and obedient Catholic can or will support an effort led by the disobedient and devious?  I know for a fact that this Catholic won’t.

Sunday, December 18, 2011

Yes, Virginia, there is a Traditional Latin Mass!

...with apologies to Francis Pharcellus Church, whose "Yes, Viriginia, there IS a Santa Claus" article appeared in 1897, and is history's most reprinted newspaper editorial. To refresh your memory, see the full original editorial at the end of this post.

Dear Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei:
I am 58 years old. Some of my liberal detractors say there will be never be a Traditional Latin Mass in our diocese. The Holy Father says, “If you see it in a motu proprio, it's so.” Please tell me the truth; will we have a Traditional Latin Mass in the Diocese of Baker?
Philothea

PHILOTHEA, your liberal detractors are wrong. They have been affected by the modernism of an age of moral relativism. They do not believe except what they see. They think that nothing can be which is not comprehensible by their little minds. All minds, Philothea, whether they be men’s or children’s, are little. In this great universe of ours man is a mere insect, an ant, in his intellect, as compared with the boundless world about him, as measured by the intelligence capable of grasping the whole of truth and knowledge. This is why there is resistance to the extraordinary form of the Mass, which opens the Mysteries of the universe to us.
Yes, Philothea, someday there will be a Traditional Latin Mass widely available. It will exist as certainly as faith, hope, and charity exist, and you know that they abound as theological virtues and give to your life its highest beauty and joy. Alas! How dreary life would be if there were no extraordinary form of the Mass! It would be as dreary as if there were no Real Presence of Jesus in the Eucharist! There would be no childlike faith then, no sacred polyphony, no Gregorian chant to make tolerable this existence. We should have no enjoyment except in sense and sight. The eternal light with which God fills our souls would be extinguished.
No Traditional Latin Mass! You might as well not have any liturgy at all! You might get the Holy Father to hire men to watch in all the Dioceses in the United States to find a Mass in the Extraordinary Form, but even if they did not find one, what would that prove? Nobody sees the Spirit of the liturgy, but that is no sign that there is no Extraordinary Form. The most Real Presence in the world is One that neither children nor men can see. Did you ever see the Holy Angels surrounding the altar at Mass? Of course not, but that's no proof that they are not there. Nobody can conceive or imagine all the wonders there are unseen and unseeable in the world.

You may tear apart the baby's rattle and see what makes the noise inside, but there is a veil covering the unseen world which not the strongest man, nor even the united strength of all the strongest men that ever lived, could tear apart. Only faith, hope, and love can push aside that curtain, and view and actually participate in the supernal beauty and glory beyond it, at Holy Mass. Is it all real? Ah, Philothea, in all this world there is nothing else real and abiding.
No TLM! Thank God! it lives, and it lives forever. A thousand years from now, Philothea, nay, ten times ten thousand years from now, it will continue to make glad the heart of the faithful who seek it.

Saturday, December 17, 2011

Advent Reflection: 4th Sunday

From a commentary by Origen of Alexandria
…What way shall we prepare for the Lord? A way by land? Could the Word of God travel such a road? Is it not rather a way within ourselves that we have to prepare for the Lord? Is it not a straight and level highway in our hearts that we are to make ready? Surely this is the way by which the Word of God enters, a way that exists in the spaciousness of the human body. The human heart is vast, broad, and capacious, if only it is pure. Would you like to know its length and breadth? See then what a vast amount of divine knowledge it can contain.
Solomon says: He gave me knowledge of all that exists; he taught me about the structure of the universe and the properties of the elements, the beginning and the end of epochs and the periods between, the variations in the seasons and the succession of the months, the revolution of the year and the position of the stars, the nature of living things and the instincts of wild animals, the force of the winds and the thoughts of human beings, the various kinds of plants and the medicinal properties of roots.
You must realize that the human heart is not small when it can contain all this. You ought to judge it not by its physical size but by its power to embrace such a vast amount of knowledge of the truth.
But so that I may convince you that the human heart is large by a simple example from daily life, let us consider this. Whatever city we may have passed through, we have in our minds. We remember its streets, walls, and buildings, what they were like and where they were situated. We have a mental picture of the roads we have traveled. In moments of quiet reflection our minds embrace the sea that we have crossed. So, as I said, the heart that can contain all this is not small!
Therefore, if what contains so much is not small, let a way be prepared in it for the Lord, a straight highway along with the Word and Wisdom of God may advance. Prepare a way for the Lord by living a good life and guard that way by good works. Let the Word of God move in you unhindered and give you a knowledge of his coming and of his mysteries. To him be glory and power for ever and ever. Amen.
(Selection from Journey with the Fathers: Commentaries on the Sunday Gospels, Year C, edited by Edith Barnecut, OSB)

Friday, December 16, 2011

Of Light Bulbs and Latin: Two Problems at St. Francis in Bend


Question: How many parishioners does it take to change the light bulbs at the new St. Francis Church?

Answer: As many as it will take to raise $12,000.
Apparently, the light bulbs on the ceiling of that church are starting to burn out, and changing them turns out to be a not-so-simple task. Due to the design of the church, changing the bulbs requires the services of a contractor who can bring in a “cherry-picker” to reach them. And of course, bringing in a piece of equipment like that requires unbolting and moving a large number of pews to make room for it.
Quite the surprise for the parish, eh?! Well, no, not exactly. It turns out that the advisory committee for the construction of the new church was warned of just this defect in the design – before ground was ever broken for the new church. And yet, the committee – and the pastor - decided to go ahead with the project. Not to mention that the plans for the church came at a cost of $50,000 – and they were not newly-developed plans; they had been previously used for a church in Washington.
I’ve heard that the Bend parish – like the Diocese of Baker - is in serious financial trouble. Is it any wonder?
Sounds to me as if St. Francis parish is in need of some “dynamic leadership” – and Bishop Skylstad has promised just that with his appointment of a new pastor, Fr. James Radloff! Personally, I know nothing about Fr. Radloff’s leadership ability. However, I do know something of his divisive ways.
To wit: last April, Fr. Radloff sent out an email which was received by many people in the diocese, and which did not please all of them. Here’s the one I received (emphasis added):
Dear Prayer Partner,
You know I don’t forward things very often, but when I do it is because they have touched my heart.  The following reflection speaks the truth.  Please forward it to all those who are as tired as I am with others forcing Latin onto us who would just like to pray the prayers at Mass in our own language.

God Bless,

Father Jim Radloff
P.O. Box 489
Sisters, OR  97759

To: Rev. James A. Radloff (shepherds4christ@msn.com)
Subject: Pray from the Heart

Mass needs to be in the language of the heart. A Columbian who speaks and understands English said, “I thank God my church has Mass in Spanish because this is the language of my heart and when I pray I pray from the heart.”  English is the language of my heart and when I pray I pray from my heart . . . in English!  So they pierce my heart when they substitute the English prayers with Latin.  Let’s make it very clear to our pastors that the English Mass needs to remain in English so that we who have only known the English Mass may continue to pray from the heart.

Puh-lease. There is so much wrong in this email message and the forwarded text that I hardly know where to begin. Let me make this point about the illogic of it: What if there’s a group in Fr. Radloff’s parish whose “language of the heart” is Vietnamese…or Polish…or Korean? Will he provide a Mass in each of those languages? There’s a reason that Latin is the UNIVERSAL language of the Church. The General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM) says: “Since faithful from different countries come together ever more frequently, it is fitting that they know how to sing together at least some parts of the Mass in Latin, especially the Creed and the Lord’s Prayer…”. And what if one’s “language of the heart” just happens to be…uh…well…Latin? Hmmm.
And besides that:

·         Latin is the official language of the Catholic Church…still…despite misinterpretations of Vatican II

·         The Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy (ahem…that’s a VATICAN II document) says, “The use of the Latin language…is to be preserved in the Latin rites.” That’s an important statement in an important document, which many seem to ignore.

·         Canon Law requires seminaries to teach our future priests Latin (though few seem to take that law seriously). D'ya suppose there's a reason for that?!

·         Redemptionis Sacramentum (2004) says: “Priests are always and everywhere permitted to celebrate Mass in Latin.” Note: it does not say they need the permission of their parishioners to do so!

A picture emerges here: Bishop Skylstad, himself quite willing to suspend Canon Law or ignore other Church documents when it suits his own agenda, has appointed a pastor to the largest parish in the Diocese, who is quite willing to do the same by: a) encouraging parishioners to pit themselves against the mind of the Church on the “issue” of Latin in the Mass; and b) alienating and marginalizing those who desire a more traditional Mass, especially those who desire the Extraordinary Form of the Mass (or the “Traditional Latin Mass”). Think about it, St. Francis parishioners. “Houston, we have a problem.”

Why the big upheaval about Latin? Why do some people resist it so vehemently? I have some ideas, which I’ll develop another time. But I do know this: Satan hates Latin.

And, apparently, he hates light bulbs you can reach, too.

“Houston…”