Thursday, December 15, 2011

Some Things Never Change: Looking at a Bishop's Record

Guest Commentary by Jerry Boyd

Some things never change. Some people don't either.
Earlier posts on this blog have documented the failure of the current Apostolic Administrator of the Diocese of Baker to follow the directives of the Holy Father in terms of facilitating the reasonable desires of the Faithful for Mass in the Extraordinary Form.  You might think that a so-called Church leader – a retired bishop - would be obedient to the will of our Pontiff.  So, when it is obvious to me that this bishop isn’t - given his direct refusal to honor reasonable requests made of him, and given his isolation of priests willing and capable of saying the Traditional Latin Mass - it causes me to wonder why.  Could it be that he, in concert with others, has his own agenda?  Could it be that said agenda is more important to him than doing the will of the Holy Father?  Could it be that his personal agenda takes precedence over the good of the people entrusted to his care?
In an effort to find answers to those questions I have looked at this Bishop’s “track record” in his past assignments. How a person performs over time is generally a good clue as to how they will perform now and in the future. Even more importantly, a look at one’s past often reveals his motivation for his current actions.
So in looking, I found this 2004 article from the Seattle Times, which really didn’t answer my questions. However, it raised many others even more serious than the ones I originally asked. The article is primarily about a lawsuit against the Diocese of Spokane for negligence in the case of a priest who was accused of and admitted to the sexual abuse of a number of minor boys. The article states:
Skylstad wrote to diocese members about what he had learned from the scandal. One lesson, he said, was this: "I also came to understand better that there really is no such thing as a supposed consensual sexual relationship between any adult and a minor."
How could anyone capable of holding a Church leadership position come to know that sex between an adult (priest) and a child is unlawful only after repeated instances of such conduct involving his priests bankrupted the diocese he led?  How could any leader, given specific and alarming information by a responsible adult about priestly misconduct, fail to take prompt action?  And how could any competent leader with a true concern for the souls entrusted to his care “forget” that he was ever given such information?
And this relates to his current actions how?  The Latin Mass, for all of its other attributes, is also symbolic of a long era in Church history marked by obedience to the Pope of Rome.  If the Mass in the Extraordinary Form is allowed to grow, that is a direct threat to those who view the pre-Vatican II era as one which limits their “initiative”, limits their “independence”, limits the attention focused on them, and  limits their “authority”.  And, previous posts have already documented Bishop Skylstad’s comment that “I am my own superior”.
The net result of all of this is that I am now even more convinced that the actions of the current Apostolic Administrator, if left unchecked, will have a lasting detrimental impact on this already struggling Diocese.  Pray with me for the appointment of a new Bishop, soon…one who will be obedient to the true teachings of the Catholic Church, a true shepherd for the people, and a true father to his priests.
Related posts:


Wednesday, December 14, 2011

An Ounce of Prevention: Praying and Pushing for a Holy Bishop

The Diocese of Baker is under the control of an Apostolic Administrator who, in my opinion, has taken and will likely continue to take actions that are unwise and unsupported by Canon Law and common sense. I could (and probably will in the near future) give some examples of what I mean by that. But for now…

The point is moot, in a way. The Apostolic Administrator will, at some point, be replaced, because a new bishop will certainly be appointed for this diocese…one of these days.  Usquoque, Domine (how long, O Lord!).  So, no matter what damage is done by Bishop Skylstad, it could conceivably be undone by a new bishop. Still, the more changes made by the Apostolic Administrator, the more difficult it will be for the new bishop to repair the damage.

But, looking at the long range future of the Diocese, we need to consider what kind of bishop might be appointed. We need to pray for a bishop who will be a good shepherd - one who will be faithful to the Magisterium of the Church, uphold correct liturgical practices, and actively cultivate our Catholic identity. If we get a wayward bishop, we’ll be stuck with him for some time to come – likely until he reaches the age of 75, when his resignation is required – no matter how heterodox he is.

In a 2008 article, Charles M. Wilson of the St. Joseph Foundation examined the question: What Happens When Bishops Are Found Wanting? The article appeared in Christifideles, the newsletter of the Foundation.

In his article, Mr. Wilson examined some specific cases of wayward bishops and commented on whether it appeared that they were corrected by Rome, and/or pressured to resign before the mandatory retirement age. This is difficult to determine, since proceedings of this manner are kept secret by the powers that be. However, Mr. Wilson’s research does indicate that at the very least, these bishops’ harmful ways were allowed to continue for quite some time. Therefore, he concludes, it’s better to start off with a solid candidate, so that corrective measures don’t have to be implemented. Here is his conclusion:

“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.” -Benjamin Franklin

Whatever our personal preferences might be, we probably will not see anytime soon a noticeable increase in the correction or discipline of diocesan bishops. And even if the number of such actions should happen to escalate, the excessive reliance on secrecy that prevails in many aspects of ecclesiastical governance will serve to keep the lay faithful in the dark.

It remains that if a bishop’s exercise of governance is problematic to the extent that it becomes evident to upright and serious-minded members of the faithful, then one might have cause to wonder if it made good sense to ordain him a bishop in the first place. It needs to be remembered that the law of the Church requires that a candidate for the episcopacy be outstanding in solid faith, good morals, piety, zeal for souls, wisdom, prudence, and human virtues, and endowed with other qualities which make him suitable to fulfill the office in question (c. 378, §1, 1º). Had these words been more carefully heeded yesterday, how much better would be the state of the Church today? Perhaps Dr. Franklin’s wise maxim should be engraved prominently above the entrances to the Congregation for Bishops, “which deals with everything concerning the appointment of bishops, even titular ones, and generally with the provision of particular Churches” (Pastor Bonus, Art. 77).

For the Diocese of Baker – and for any vacant see – there are two things that the laity can do. First of all, we can and should pray for a good and holy shepherd to lead us in the true teachings of the Church. Here is a prayer for the election of a bishop:

Lord God, you are our eternal shepherd and guide.
In your mercy grant the Church (of Baker) a shepherd
who will walk in your ways
and whose watchful care will bring us your blessing.
We ask this through Our Lord…

But we may also make known our desires. There can be no doubt that the powers-that-be are aware that a growing number of the faithful are voicing their discontent with the sorry state of catechesis that has been ongoing for decades. It is perfectly reasonable for the faithful to write to the Apostolic Nuncio to express a desire for a faithful bishop!

So…have you written your letter yet?! I have mentioned the same thought previously. Go here for the address and a sample letter.

Pray. Fast. Write a letter.

Monday, December 12, 2011

The Glass Ceiling Over the Traditional Latin Mass

So…you’d like your parish to offer the extraordinary form of the Mass. How do you get that to happen?

On the WDTPRS blog, Fr. Z has had a couple of entries lately on this basic question. His standard answer is this (and it is a good one!):

First, keep in mind that since Summorum Pontificum went into effect in September 2007 pastors of parishes, not diocesan bishops, implement celebrations of the Extraordinary Form in their parishes. The diocesan bishop no longer makes these decisions. Were a pastor of a parish to start a regular TLM, and were the diocesan bishop to demand that the priest stop, that priest’s case would probably receive a very favorable hearing at the Pontifical Commission “Ecclesia Dei” in Rome.

In other words, we look to the authoritative teachings and documents of the Church to determine the rights and responsibilities of both the laity and the clergy. In this case, there is a document - a motu proprio - called Summorum Pontificum, along with an instruction on that document called Universae Ecclesiae, which give a priest the right to say the EF Mass without obtaining the permission of the diocesan bishop. We also have the Pontifical Commission “Ecclesia Dei” in Rome, which has the authority to act on matters brought to its attention regarding problems and issues that the faithful may face in obtaining the EF Mass.

This is good, and is certainly understood by most of those who support access to the EF Mass. However, it is misconstrued and abused by those who do not support access to the EF Mass, including, sadly, a number of US bishops.

It’s one thing for a priest to assert his right to provide the EF Mass for those faithful who desire it. It’s another thing for him to actually be able to accomplish the feat. If his bishop tells him to cease and desist from offering the Mass, a priest’s most prudent choice is to obey that unfair and unlawful order. Why? Because, any priest doing something the bishop doesn’t like, even if he is within his rights to do it, faces reprisals, to put it bluntly. There are plenty of examples out there. Email me for a few if you don’t know of any yourself.

Even if a priest decides to report the bishop’s denial of the EF Mass to the PCED, the wheels turn slowly, I can tell you from experience. It doesn’t appear to me that much is going on by way of fraternal correction in these matters. But then, one never knows what is going on behind the scenes. We can always hope.

There’s another aspect to the stubborn (and unlawful) refusal of some bishops to allow parishes to provide the EF Mass. It is summed up nicely by a reader of Fr. Z’s blog, which was quoted there and appears here with Fr. Z’s emphases and comments:

We are struggling with our diocese over the definition of that term, as they ["they"? Diocesan officials?] want to say a stable group is thirty Catholics [NO!] who will pledge themselves to attend the EF. Naturally, we had numbers approaching thirty when our TLM was pushed out of the parishes three years ago. Now we total about fifteen or so, and even though the same people have attended the TLM more or less faithfully (we even found ourselves in a chapel of a secular retirement home for about two years) for four years, the diocese still tells us we are not a stable group. By the way, we had a priest in the area willing to offer this Mass for us. But the bishop banished him to the hinterlands. Now he travels about 300 miles once a month to offer this Mass for our group. Just what IS a “stable group”?

A couple of tactics are evident here: first, the diocesan officials tell the group they don’t have enough people to warrant an EF Mass. Second, in order to say that “it’s just not possible” to provide the Mass for lack of a priest who is capable of saying it, the bishop moves the only available priest as far away as possible from the group that wants the EF Mass. Of course, the bishop will always be able to give a “good reason” why that particular priest had to be moved to Timbuktu.

This has happened in the Diocese of Baker as well. The provision of a monthly EF Mass sponsored by the Society of St. Gregory the Great in Bend, Oregon, was effectively terminated through a series of actions that all came with the excuse that “there’s just no other choice”; after removing all the options, the bishop then was able to declare, “It’s just not possible” to provide the EF Mass. And yet it had been possible for three years prior to the transfer of Bishop Robert F. Vasa and the arrival of Apostolic Administrator Bishop William S. Skylstad.

Here’s the sequence of events:

·         On March 22, 2011, the Apostolic Administrator restricted - without cause - the exercise of the sacerdotal faculties of the priest who had been regularly offering this monthly EF Mass in Bend since 2008 – refusing to allow him to celebrate the EF Mass in Bend. This case has been under review in Rome for more than 7 months now, tied up in the bureaucracy of Congregations debating whose responsibility it is to deal with it.

·         On September 17, 2011, the Apostolic Administrator transferred from Bend to a remote corner of the Diocese (and we’re talking a BIG diocese, here) the only other local priest willing and able to assume the responsibilities of offering these Masses for the Society. There just was “no other choice” as he was the only priest they could send to a parish in need.

·         The Society repeatedly requested that the pastor of St. Francis of Assisi Church in Bend (Father Francis X. Ekwugha) provide a priest to offer the EF Mass. Of course, he was not able to do so as his associate pastor was the one transferred to the hinterlands.

·         When the Society failed to obtain satisfaction from Fr. Francis, it subsequently sought assistance from Bishop Skylstad, following the guidelines laid out in Summorum Pontificum. Bishop Skylstad demurred, claiming it was “not possible” for him to provide a priest to say the monthly EF Mass.

·         On November 29, 2011, Bishop Skylstad dismissed without cause the pastor of St. Francis of Assisi parish in Bend (a pastor who had been sympathetic to the goal of the Society to provide the EF Mass), and appointed a new pastor who has been outspoken in his dislike of Latin, even for use in the ordinary form of the Mass.

Note that this can and does happen in any diocese. The bishop need only throw up his hands and say, “Sorry! No can do!” There are similar stories elsewhere.

So here you have two examples – one of which is quite well-documented – of dioceses in which the EF is being effectively squelched. This is a violation of the rights of the faithful, and it is an egregious and scandalous example of the disobedience of bishops to the authority of the Holy Father and the Church. And yet, it is often the “traditionalists”, those people who want to “force Latin onto others”, the ones who want to “turn back the clock”, who are accused of infidelity to the Church.

Ironic, isn’t it?


Related posts on this blog:

Sunday, December 11, 2011

Disaster Response in the Church ("The Vortex")

Have I mentioned that you should be watching “The Vortex” at RealCatholicTV?
Michael Voris’s recent episodes are a stirring cry to arms. Our Church is in a disaster, he says in the one inserted below, and he tells us exactly why. Sadly, many people are not aware of this, because they have been left largely uncatechized, and they do not know their faith. Many people who dissent from church teaching think it is perfectly okay to do so, and to continue to receive Holy Communion anyway. Our shepherds are not doing their job. (Note: There are a few bishops emerging with clear calls to orthodoxy, and there are priests here and there who are teaching and preaching the truth, although they are oftentimes not supported by their bishops.)

At the end of this “Vortex” episode, Mr. Voris says:
What is left is nothing more than pockets of faithful here and there, people emerging from their hideouts after the war. Okay, so be it. Look at the ground around you, survey the landscape, understand the big picture. And take note of the disaster that the Church is in and now commit to doing something about it. Admit the problem and resolve to fix it. Not on the leadership level, laity, that’s not the area for us. Resolve to fix it on the level where you can - where I can – with ourselves first, and then with the people in your life. Learn the faith, know the faith, teach others the faith. Pour yourselves into the sacrifice that this will take, and charge full ahead. Leave the establishment church parishes to finish burning to the ground, and grab hold of the authentic faith…the magisterium…the ancient faith.


Go only to faithful parishes with priests and pastors in solid, visible communion with the Holy Father, where abuses at Mass are seen for what they really are: abuses. Don’t send your children to Catholic schools that aren’t Catholic, which means most of them. Don’t read or listen to supposedly Catholic outfits and news sources that don’t give you the whole picture. Don’t give your money to establishment church efforts that do not promote the salvation of souls. Disasters require emergency responses. We are in a disaster. Time for an emergency response.


If you are a faithful Catholic – not a cafeteria Catholic, not a Catholic in name only, not a twice-a-year Catholic – I urge you to take Voris’s words to heart. I urge you to take action in your own sphere of influence. Is your parish following the liberal path? Is your pastor saying things that don’t quite square up with Church teaching?  Respectfully point out the errors and ask for a change. If you are met with resistance, leave. Find another parish if at all possible. And if circumstances require that you continue to attend Mass at that parish, at least put your money into a parish or another effort (like, for instance, the Carmelite Monks of Wyoming) that is doing the right thing.

The same idea holds for a diocese. If your diocese is putting money in questionable areas, or if your diocese fails to provide (or enforce!) good, solid catechesis for the parishes, then don’t fund your diocese.

Finally, if your diocese has a vacant see, write a letter. Write to the Apostolic Nuncio, to the Congregation for Bishops, to the Congregation for Clergy…write and plead for the appointment of a holy bishop who will be a pastor to the faithful and a caring father to the priests. Go here for a list of Vatican addresses. Also note that it is possible to send your letter to the Apostolic Nuncio and ask that it be delivered via the diplomatic pouch. I've been told that this is a more reliable way of getting your mail delivered.

It’s time to stand up and be counted on the side of the true Catholic faith.

Saturday, December 10, 2011

Advent Reflection: Gaudete Sunday

It’s Gaudete Sunday – we are joyful! The Lord is coming, and He is getting nearer! In our secular lives, we may be thinking, “Christmas is coming. It’s getting closer. Am I ready?” And maybe we are happy because Christmas is closer, or maybe we start to panic over the presents we haven’t bought yet. Too often, I think, we keep our devotional life from touching our secular life. We don’t let the joy of the nearness of the Christ Child overcome the anxiety of “Christmas stuff” – the decorating, the parties, the gift-giving.

The joy we feel at the thought of the first coming of Jesus, when he arrived as a little baby in the manger, is different from the joy we feel at the thought of the second coming. When the Lord comes again, it will be a time for awe and some trepidation. “Am I ready?” we must ask ourselves again. Am I truly ready to receive the Lord, to stand before the Just One who sees all my sins?

The following is from a homily of Origen on the Gospel of Luke; it’s not on this Sunday’s gospel reading, but I thought it was an interesting meditation, given all the indications that persecution of Christians, and especially Catholics, is on the increase in this country. Are we ready for that? Are we ready to stand strong for the Lord, even when our very livelihood is threatened by those who want to outlaw Catholic thought and teaching? And will we still be awaiting Him with joy in the face of persecution?

Origen says this:

“I suggest that the faithful are like a heap of unsifted grain, and that the wind represents the temptations which assail them and show up the wheat and chaff among them. When your soul is overcome by some temptation, it is not the temptation that turns you into chaff; the temptation simply discloses the stuff you are made of. On the other hand, when you endure temptations bravely it is not the temptation that makes you faithful and patient; temptation merely brings to light the hidden virtues of patience and fortitude that have been present in you all along. Do you think I had any other purpose in speaking to you, said the Lord to Job, than to reveal our virtue? In another text he declares, I humbled you and made you feel the pangs of hunger in order to find out what was in your heart.

“In the same way, a storm will not allow a house to stand firm if it is built upon sand. If you wish to build a house, you must build it upon rock. Then any storms that arise will not demolish your handiwork, whereas the house built upon sand will totter, proving thereby that it is not well founded.

“So while all is yet quiet, before the storm gathers, before the squalls begin to bluster or the waves to swell, let us concentrate all our efforts on the foundations of our building and construct our house with the many strong, interlocking bricks of God’s commandments. Then when cruel persecution is unleashed like some fearful tornado against Christians we shall be able to show that our house is built upon Christ Jesus our rock.

“Far be it from us to deny Christ when that time comes. But if anyone should do so, let that person realize that it was not at the moment of his public denial that his apostasy took place. Its seeds and root had been hidden within him for a long time; persecution only brought into the open and made public what was already there. Let us pray to the Lord then that we may be firm and solid buildings that no storm can overthrow, founded on the rock of our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory and power for ever and ever. Amen.”

(Selection from Journey with the Fathers: Commentaries on the Sunday Gospels, Year C, edited by Edith Barnecut, OSB; emphases added)

Are you ready?

Friday, December 9, 2011

St. Francis Parish Council Email: A Few Comments

I’ve been made aware of an email which some say was sent out by the St. Francis Parish Council; the opening paragraph reads:
TO ALL OUR ACOLYTES, SACRISTANS, EXTRAORDINARY MINISTERS, AND MEMBERS OF THE LITURGY COMMITTEE:
  We know that some people in the Parish have received e-mails, or have seen items on face-book (or other social media) which express anger at the Diocesan decision to replace Father Francis with such little notice. Tragically for Fr. Francis himself, and for our entire Parish family, many of these messages are inflammatory, or include statements that are not based on fact. In some of these messages Bishop Skylstad is vilified as prejudiced and uncaring. Most show a lack of the very love of Christ that Fr. Francis has made a hallmark of his time here as Pastor.  All of us who minister to our brothers and sisters should recognize that one of the most damaging things that can be done to the Body of Christ is to generate or spread false rumors about the Shepard [sic] sent to lead us.  Bishop Skylstad, by virtue of his Office, is charged with the care of his flock (all the priests and parishioners in the Diocese) and because of that, we need to be respectful of his decisions. 
Well, I don’t know anything about inflammatory messages, statements not based on fact, or false rumors; I haven’t seen any of that myself. But I do know these facts.


1) Bishop Skylstad violated Canon Law in the manner in which he dismissed Fr. Fancis Ekwugha.

2) Bishop Skylstad violated Canon Law in initially saying that he would install Fr. Radloff as parish administrator; administrators are not installed.

3) In a number of significant cases, Bishop Skylstad’s actions over the last 10 months have gone beyond what an Apostolic Administrator should do while a diocese awaits the appointment of a new bishop. (I have heard that he was given “all the powers of a bishop” with this appointment; even if that is true, his actions are creating problems for the in-coming bishop, and he should arguably have shown some restraint).

4) Bishop Skylstad has acted against the directives of the Holy Father expressed in Summorum Pontificum and Universae Ecclesiae (the motu proprio and its accompanying instruction, which liberalized the celebration of the “traditional Latin Mass” and made clear that the faithful who desire it should have access to it.

These are facts. They can be substantiated. On each count, it doesn’t matter whether or not Bishop Skylstad had the good of the parish or the good of the diocese in mind; his motivation is not the issue. The fact is, he has violated Canon Law, and he has acted against the Holy Father’s expressed desires and directives.

Bishop Skylstad is not the bishop of this diocese; he is the administrator. However, I imagine he still has the duty to care for the flock – ALL of the flock, as indicated in the email statement above. Certainly, a bishop cannot please all of the people all of the time. However, he is not called upon to please the people. He is called upon to care for their souls. Violating Canon Law is not a good way to go about caring for the souls of the faithful. In addition, when a bishop actively works against the directives of the Holy Father, he is being disobedient. A disobedient bishop cannot expect obedience from the sheep of his flock.
As I have written previously, a bishop’s general authority over his diocese is very evident in even a cursory reading of Lumen Gentium (Vatican II’s Dogmatic Constitution on the Church):
  • Bishops preside “in God’s stead over the flock of which they are the shepherds…” (LG, §21).

  • They are “teachers endowed with the authority of Christ, who preach the faith to the people assigned to them, the faith which is destined to inform their thinking and direct their conduct” (LG, §25).

  • They “have the obligation of fostering and safeguarding the unity of the faith and of upholding the discipline which is common to the whole Church…” (LG, §23).

The faithful are also reminded of their duty toward their bishops. Notice, though, the qualifier at the beginning of the paragraph (emphasis added):

Bishops who teach in communion with the Roman Pontiff are to be revered by all as witnesses of divine and Catholic truth; the faithful, for their part, are obliged to submit to their bishops’ decision, made in the name of Christ, in matters of faith and morals, and to adhere to it with a ready and respectful allegiance of mind. (LG, §25)

When a priest is acting and/or teaching contrary to the magisterium of the Church, a lay person can discuss the issue with the priest, and can report the misconduct to the bishop. What should a lay person do when the bishop acts in ways contrary to the faith? Just as with a priest, and just as in dealing with secular officials, one goes to the offending party’s superior. Who is a bishop’s superior?
Let me relate a little story about a discussion I and another person had with Bishop Skylstad. As representatives of the Society of St. Gregory the Great, we were unhappy with actions he had taken. We noted that Canon Law says:
Can. 1737 ß1 A person who contends that he or she has been injured by a decree, can for any just motive have recourse to the hierarchical Superior of the one who issued the decree. The recourse can be proposed before the author of the decree, who must immediately forward it to the competent hierarchical Superior. (emphasis added)
Bringing this canon to Bishop Skylstad’s attention, I asked him to identify his hierarchical superior. He answered, “I am my own superior.”
Not so. A bishop is not his own superior. Even though the Holy Father is considered “first among equals”, he does in fact have the power to appoint bishops and to remove them from a particular see. So, a bishop must still listen to the Holy Father. Bishop Skylstad, when pressed, did admit that his superior was “probably” the Congregation for the Clergy. If we wrote a letter seeking recourse regarding his actions, I asked, would he then “immediately forward it to” his hierarchical superior, as the law dictates? His answer: “Probably not.”
These are facts, observed by two individuals.
While we are certainly called to obey our pastors and bishops, it is also important – and required of us – that we know our faith. And this leads to other rights and responsibilities.
Canon 212 ß3 [The faithful] have the right, indeed at times the duty, in keeping with their knowledge, competence and position, to manifest to the sacred Pastors their views on matters which concern the good of the Church. They have the right also to make their views known to others of Christ's faithful, but in doing so they must always respect the integrity of faith and morals, show due reverence to the Pastors and take into account both the common good and the dignity of individuals. (emphasis added)
There is much more to be said about the statement in that email.
Stay tuned.
In the meantime, if you haven’t read the entire email, simply click on “read more” to see the whole thing.

Monday, December 5, 2011

Bishop Skylstad, There Oughta Be a Law! Oh...wait...

The situation in Bend gets curiouser and curiouser, and it does indeed seem like we are headed through the looking glass, where things are all backwards. Be sure to see the guest commentary, too.

A message making the rounds from Fr. Radloff says:

Although I will officially become pastor of Saint Francis Church on December 17, 2011, the Installation Mass HAS BEEN MOVED to the Octave of Christmas, Thursday, December 29, 2011, 7:00 PM at the new Saint Francis Church on 27th Street. 

So…even though Bishop Skylstad has “granted an extension” to Fr. Francis, and wants to be “pastoral, charitable, and canonically correct”, Fr. Radloff maintains he’s already been guaranteed the position of pastor at St. Francis. And I expressly recall that Bishop Skylstad used the term  “Administrator” in his previous communiqué. Perhaps he has changed his mind.

But what about “due process” – acting in a “canonically correct” manner? Or is the bishop simply going through the motions, acting upon his own foregone conclusion? That does not sound like a just process to me.

I’m not a canon lawyer, but I can read. Let's take a look at Canon Law in the section entitled, “The Procedure For The Removal Of Parish Priests”. The pertinent canons are 1740 through 1741.

Can. 1740 When the ministry of any parish priest has for some reason become harmful or at least ineffective, even though this occurs without any serious fault on his part, he can be removed from the parish by the diocesan Bishop.

Canon 1741 lists a number of grave reasons for which a parish priest can lawfully be removed, but the bishop doesn’t necessarily have to have one of those reasons for the dismissal; any one of them would strengthen the bishop’s case, though.

Bishop Skylstad himself has said in an email that “the reasons for making my decision were not based on inappropriate behavior or violation of personal boundaries”. And I have heard from a source close to Fr. Francis that Bishop Skylstad offered no reasons for the dismissal beyond “it’s time for a change”.  

Here’s the next few canons (all emphases mine):

Can. 1742 ß1 If an investigation shows that there exists a reason mentioned in Can. 1740, the Bishop is to discuss the matter with two parish priests from a group stably chosen for this purpose by the council of priests, at the proposal of the Bishop. If he then believes that he should proceed with the removal, the Bishop must, for validity, indicate to the parish priest the reason and the arguments, and persuade him in a fatherly manner to resign his parish within fifteen days.

Can. 1743 The resignation of the parish priest can be given not only purely and simply, but even upon a condition, provided the condition is one which the Bishop can lawfully accept and does in fact accept.

Can. 1744 ß1 If the parish priest has not replied within the days prescribed, the Bishop is to renew his invitation and extend the canonical time within which a reply is to be made.

So, it looks like the parish priest has some options as far as “extensions”, and the bishop is to be charitable in granting them.

Next, we find that the priest has further rights if he opposes the action. The bishop has some responsibilities if this is the case. They are outlined in this canon:

Can. 1745 If, however, the parish priest opposes the case put forward and the reasons given in it, but advances arguments which seem to the Bishop to be insufficient, to act validly the Bishop must:

1ƒ invite him to inspect the acts of the case and put together his objections in a written answer, indeed to produce contrary evidence if he has any;

2ƒ after this, complete the instruction of the case, if this is necessary, and weigh the matter with the same parish priests mentioned in Can. 1742 ß1, unless, because of some impossibility on their part, others are to be designated;

3ƒ finally, decide whether or not the parish priest is to be removed, and without delay issue the appropriate decree.

I know there's a lot more to interpreting and applying Canon Law than just reading the canons, but at the same time, there are some things in the above sections that seem pretty straight-forward. You can decide for yourself. Maybe we could run it by Dr. Ed Peters... In the meantime, I think Bishop Skylstad has some explaining to do, and I hope he is called upon to do so by his superiors.

If Bishop Skylstad wants to be canonically correct, there are a number of steps to go through, and he’s already skipped a couple of them.

If Bishop Skylstad wants to be pastoral, he should not be rushing through this procedure, skipping steps, and trying to force his own agenda on the priest, the parish, and the diocese. Canon Law is there for a reason. Bishop Skylstad is not above the law, and it is scandalous for him to take actions that appear to indicate that he thinks he is.

If Bishop Skylstad wanted to be charitable, he would not be allowing Fr. Radloff to flaunt his new “pastorship” before it is even a reality. He would be taking the process seriously, which means that there might not be a vacancy at St. Francis Parish in Bend after all.

Usquequo, Domine?